By October, the next 39 lots at Manor in the Foothills on Best Road already had graded pads, roads and utilities. Smithbilt Homes had built all of it after the Blount County Planning Commission gave the phase preliminary approval in June. On Thursday, Oct. 22, the same commission voted 6-5 to deny the final plat. The Daily Times reported that Josh Sanderson of Smithbilt told commissioners, "we installed everything based on the regulations."
If you're comparing Maryville with other Knoxville suburbs, that vote matters more than any listing price you've seen. The rules for new housing are tightening on both sides of Maryville's city limits at once, and the homes that still get built are priced above the range most East Tennessee buyers can afford. A family shopping in the $300,000s around Maryville is mostly shopping resale homes, and that is the thinnest part of the regional inventory.
A subdivision faces a final plat denial
Manor's final plat denial came after preliminary approval. The site is "already padded out," as Commissioner David Corwin put it while arguing against the denial.
The commissioners who voted no pointed to Best Road. Commissioner Robert Simerly said the project rested on a traffic study that was "8 to 10 years old." Commissioner Danny Kimsey cited infrastructure, lot size and open space. The county attorney had warned beforehand that a denial could invite a lawsuit over the developer's vested rights. Maryville first approved the subdivision on Feb. 19, 2018, back when the city still held regional planning authority beyond its limits. The Daily Times notes that developers have sued Blount County several times since 2016 and that the county has not yet won one of those suits.
The supply effect reaches past these 39 lots. According to Sanderson, 97 more lots in Manor's original master plan haven't yet been submitted for preliminary approval. Whatever happens next, those lots now face an uncertain timeline.
The county is rewriting the rules for the next subdivision
The Manor vote came from a newly seated Planning Commission. A term that began Sept. 1 brought in five new members. Four are county commissioners, and The Daily Times describes them as having run "on a controlling growth platform." Builders saw where things were heading at the September meeting. Barak Saltzman, D.R. Horton's division president for East Tennessee, asked the commission to reconsider the county's cluster-development rules, which were rewritten in 2023 to raise minimum lot sizes and add buffering and open-space requirements. As The Daily Times reported, he said:
"The cluster development and the updated regulations have doubled the costs of a buildable finished lot with utilities installed. ... The reality is that new cluster development homes will be in the high 500s or low 600s."
D.R. Horton built CreekBridge and Best Farms under the earlier rules. No cluster development has been submitted since the 2023 change. Blount County Mayor Jared Anderson used the same meeting to say that if a resolution reducing minimum lot sizes reached him, "I do plan to veto it."
In October, the County Commission went further. It sent a 12-month moratorium on accepting applications for apartments, multifamily projects and larger subdivisions to the Planning Commission. WBIR's headline said commissioners "approve" the moratorium, but the pause is not in effect. The Planning Commission still has to review it, a public hearing has to be held, and the measure has to return to the full commission for a final vote. The Daily Times reports that January is the earliest that vote could happen. An attempt to remove subdivisions from the moratorium failed 6-14.
The new homes the county allows will sit on bigger lots, take longer to approve, and cost more per lot. The Daily Times puts the proposed moratorium's cutoff at more than 10 lots, and WBIR describes it as 10 or more.
Inside the city line, projects stall over sewer service and power capacity
You might expect growth to shift into Maryville itself. For about seven or eight years, the city avoided that by policy. In January 2026, The Daily Times reported that Vice Mayor Fred Metz described a council practice of not annexing residential property and tied it to the cost of building additional schools. According to a Daily Times preview of the city's fall agenda, at an August 2025 work session city staff recommended dropping that policy. Council members agreed, while saying they would keep scrutinizing each annexation request closely.
Big Springs Road shows what scrutiny looks like in practice. A 25-townhome concept for 5.62 acres at 1305 Big Springs Road came with an annexation request in May. As The Daily Times reported, Assistant City Manager Kevin Stoltenberg said sewer extensions to the area were still several years away and that the developer would have to connect at its own expense once service arrived. A staff report also flagged a shortage of transformers and other electrical equipment needed to support that density. The council vote in June failed on a procedural ruling after two members abstained. The request went back to the Planning Commission, failed to win a recommendation there, and was withdrawn. "The property will remain in the county," Land Development Administrator Michael Brusseau told The Daily Times.
Here is where the projects that would add homes around Maryville stand as of late October 2026:
| Project | Location | Jurisdiction | Where it stands |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manor in the Foothills, Phase 4, Unit 3 | Best Road | Blount County | 39-lot final plat denied Oct. 22, 2026 |
| 62 townhomes | Morganton Road at William Blount Drive | Blount County | Approved with recommendations in May; developers opted to add a turn lane after meeting with TDOT |
| 25 townhomes | 1305 Big Springs Road | Annexation request | Withdrawn; parcel stays in the county |
| 90 townhomes | 22 acres off Montvale Road | City of Maryville | Denied by the Board of Zoning Appeals in February 2026 |
| 13 duplexes, 26 units | 114 Dotson Memorial Road | City of Maryville | BZA approval in September; preliminary plat on the Oct. 19 Planning Commission agenda |
| Morgan Landing, 16 attached units | Robert C. Jackson Drive across from Worthington Boulevard | City of Maryville | On the Oct. 20 BZA agenda |
The Daily Times covered the Morganton Road townhome approval and the Dotson Memorial Road duplexes. The city's October Board of Zoning Appeals agenda and Oct. 19 Planning Commission agenda list the pending city items. The Montvale Road site had already been turned down once, when a plan for about 68 single-family homes was denied over access concerns. WVLT reported that the 90-townhome version met the same result. The projects that are advancing inside the city are duplex clusters with a few dozen units at most. Larger proposals in the city have stalled over infrastructure, and in the county they stall over the rules.
The regional numbers show the same squeeze
East Tennessee REALTORS' September 2026 Market Pulse covers August 2026 sales across its footprint. It is regional data, not Blount County alone, but it matches what's happening around Maryville. In August 2026, new construction made up just 10.7% of home sales, down from 12% in 2025 and the lowest monthly share since 2022. The report says the median price of new homes sold stayed above $400,000 all year. It adds that new homes generally don't fall into the most popular price range because of land costs, process delays, materials and labor.
The most popular range is $300,000 to $400,000. According to the same report, the typical home sold in that range has three bedrooms, two baths and about 2,000 square feet, and homes in that range made up nearly 30% of sales year to date. As of Sept. 30, 2026, only about 1,200 of them were actively listed across East Tennessee, roughly 14% of available inventory.
The broader numbers look calmer. The August 2026 median single-family sale price was $371,375, down 1.3% from a year earlier, and total inventory was up 4.5%. Half the homes sold went under contract in 27 days or less. Those averages hide the gap. More homes are for sale overall, but the most-sold category is still scarce, and the new-home pipeline that could add to it is being priced, by D.R. Horton's estimate, into the high $500s.
Questions to ask when you compare a new build with a resale home
When you weigh a new-construction home on the county side against a resale home in town, where the lot sits shapes more than its address. A few questions bring that into focus:
- Is the lot inside Maryville or in unincorporated Blount County? The projects above went to different boards depending on that line, and The Daily Times reported that projects Maryville approved outside its limits were moved to county jurisdiction when the city gave up its regional planning role.
- Has the phase received final plat approval? Manor shows how late in the process a vote can turn against a project.
- How large is the builder's next phase? The proposed county moratorium is aimed at larger subdivisions and is not yet final.
Your builder, the planning staff for the city or county, and a real estate attorney can confirm how any of this applies to a specific lot.
Property taxes differ across the line too. In June 2026, Blount County adopted a FY2026–27 rate of $1.29 per $100 of assessed value, down from $1.59 after reappraisal. The Daily Times cautioned that a lower rate does not guarantee a lower bill for every owner, because home values changed by different amounts. The City of Maryville's FY2027 budget sets a city rate of $1.36 per $100, and the city's property tax page confirms that property inside the city is taxed by both the city and the county. This is general information, not legal or tax advice, so check what applies to your own property with the county trustee, a tax professional or a real estate attorney.
The county board's next workshop is Thursday, Nov. 12, and its monthly meeting is Thursday, Nov. 19. The moratorium is expected to return for a final vote no earlier than January.
If you own a three-bedroom home around Maryville in the price range where new construction has largely stopped competing, your home is part of the smallest slice of the regional inventory. Page Pratt can walk you through how that applies to your street and your timing. Start with a free home valuation.